What people said about markcmphillips’s jam Sloop John B

7 Comments (since 13 Oct 2012)

8 years, 8 days ago

Bukowski

From one of the greatest albums ever made.

8 years, 8 days ago

kemiladashdot

Seemingly "doomed" to be number 2 in many 100 greatest albums lists.

8 years, 8 days ago

d0minic

I have a Top 10 of which this is one @kemiladashdot I think music is just took varied & subjective to have a definitive No. 1

8 years, 8 days ago

kemiladashdot

@LadyGulag Agree totally, just meant the big published polls- Q Magazine, Rolling Stone, NME, whatever that consistently put Sgt. Pepper at No.1 and Pet Sounds at No.2.

8 years, 8 days ago

d0minic

no surprise @kemiladashdot to me, Sgt Pepper is one of their more dated albums, burdened by it's massive reputation.

8 years, 8 days ago

kemiladashdot

@LadyGulag Again true, I imagine Sgt. P. was one of those, you had to be there kinda records, by the time I got there - too much else had happened & I was never able to fully appreciate in the way others were able.

8 years, 8 days ago

d0minic

indeed @kemiladashdot I feel that Revolver & The White Album have a timeless freshness to them that Sgt. P lacks as ground breaking as it was.